Protesting doesn’t “DO” anything

The other day a colleague told me that he doesn’t understand why people block the streets and disrupt his commute to protest. According to him, protesting doesn’t “DO” anything.

Immigration Ban Protest at Chicago’s Federal Plaza | source: wikimedia

When I questioned him further he told me “no serious policy change” has come about as a result of protest action. After I cited the civil rights movement of the 1960s, I was told “well that was different.”

Why?

These protests sprung from the centuries-old, systemic oppression of people of color by whites. The entire movement can be attributed to a marginalized minority group with no other course of redress. A government “of the people, by the people, and for the people” consisted and served only the interests of white Americans. Folks of color, primarily black people, were so disenfranchised and downtrodden by the societal apparatus that they had no other way to express themselves, vent their frustration, or be heard.

In the days before the Internet and social media, taking to the streets was akin to sharing a status or posting to a trending hashtag. Standing up for what you believe in, disrupting a majority group’s privilege, being heard, and being seen is, quite frankly, DOING a lot.

Congressman John Lewis as a member of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) is beaten by white police officers on March 7, 1965. | source: US Embassy The Hague

Being in the streets, eating up government resources, reminding the majority that America does not stand for tyranny, and disrupting a status quo that seeks to dehumanize and disenfranchise minority groups calls attention. It calls a lot of attention.

But what about “counter-protesters”? Don’t they call a lot of attention too?

Today: A Trump rally where a black woman is beaten and verbally abused. Is it so different from a crowd of white people beating, fire hosing, and turning dogs upon black people in the streets?

Today: “Counter-protesters” in Berkeley who beat victims senseless while the police look on with indifference, or are complicit themselves. Dallas. Ferguson. Detroit. Cleveland. Baton Rouge.

A 1942 sign in a Detroit suburb. Make America Great Again? | source: wikimedia

So “counter-protesting” is not a real thing. It’s a term coined by modern day oppressors to whitewash acts of intimidation. Extra-judicial killings of minorities are not new to America. The shame of lynching, abuse, and systematic violence as a form of oppression continues.

The extra-judicial killing, lynching, of Laura Nelson in May 1911. | source: wikimedia

Recently race-based violence has superseded justice and imposed death sentences upon Dontre Hamilton, Eric Garner, John Crawford III, Michael Brown, Ezell Ford, Dante Parker, Tanisha Anderson, Akai Gurley, Tamir Rice, Rumain Brisbon, Jerame Reid, and Laquan McDonald. for being of color. And it keeps happening. Again. And again.

So the next time you hear someone speaking from a place blinded by a history of privilege, check them. Check yourself. And acknowledge that protesting is a legitimate way of DOING something. Anything. For some people, it’s the only option they have.

Free Maribel Trujillo Diaz

Photo courtesy the Trujillo Family.

CLINIC needs your help as we work to keep Maribel Trujillo Diaz, a mother of four from Hamilton, Ohio, from being deported back to Mexico, a country she has not called home in 15 years. Currently her deportation is scheduled for Tuesday, April 11.

Maribel is the primary financial provider for her family, which includes a three-year-old child who suffers from seizures and a husband who is unable to work full time. She was brought to Immigration and Custom Enforcement’s attention in 2007 during an immigration raid at a Koch Foods, Inc. chicken plant. She was not charged with a crime then, and has complied with her mandatory check-ins over the years.

During her April 3 check-in, she was told she was not a priority for deportation, and to come back in May. Nevertheless, she was picked up by ICE two days later, while on her way to work. Maribel is the latest victim of inconsistent immigration policies and practices by the current administration. We are told recent arrivals and people with criminal records are the priorities for deportation, but more often people like Maribel are being taken from their families.

We are including CLINIC’s press release expressing our outrage surrounding Maribel’s detainment and scheduled deportation, as well as a statement from the Archdiocese of Cincinnati. Here are a few news stories telling Maribel’s story:

·        Cincinnati.comhttp://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/politics/2017/04/06/archdioese-cincinnati-calls-scheduled-deportation-fairfield-mother-cruel-and-unnaceptable/100117634/

·         The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/apr/06/ice-immigration-maribel-trujillo-deportation-mexico

·         WHIO: http://www.whio.com/news/local/mexican-woman-with-work-permit-detained-ice-near-her-fairfield-home/eGCbXjLwhao8zvCg53sXqM/

·         The Hamilton Journal: http://www.journal-news.com/news/local/mexican-woman-with-work-permit-detained-ice-near-her-fairfield-home/eGCbXjLwhao8zvCg53sXqM/

·         The Catholic Telegraph: http://www.thecatholictelegraph.com/archdiocese-decries-ice-removal-of-mother-of-four/40844

·         Fusion: http://fusion.net/ice-seized-a-mother-of-special-needs-kids-with-no-crimi-1794090284

·         Univision: http://www.univision.com/noticias/inmigracion/el-dilema-de-una-madre-indocumentada-detenida-en-ohio-que-hacer-con-sus-4-hijos-estadounidenses

We are generating support by collecting signatures with this petition, and amplifying our message to ICE (@ICEgov) and the Department of Homeland Security (@DHSgov) using the hashtags #FreeMaribel or #MaribelLibertad. Specifically, supporters are encouraged to contact their members of Congress to speak up for Maribel and work to have her released.

Ohio residents, especially, should to contact Sens. Rob Portman, R-OH, and Sherrad Brown, D-OH. Portman can be can be reached via fax at 614-469-7719, and his Twitter handle is @senrobportman. Brown’s twitter handle is @SenSherrodBrown.

Sample tweets include:

·         I support the release of Maribel Trujillo! Her family needs her. @ICEgov @DHSgov #FreeMaribel

·         Making immigrants like Maribel leave does not make the country safer. It only terrorizes vulnerable people. @ICEgov @DHSgov #FreeMaribel

·         @ICEgov @DHSgov Returning Maribel to Mexico would put her life at risk, and potentially the lives of her U.S. citizen children. #FreeMaribel

·         @ICEgov @DHSgov Separating young children from their mother will cause unnecessary harm. I am against #detention and #deportation. #FreeMaribel

Here are some message points on which we want the conversation to focus:

·         Maribel is the primary breadwinner for her family. Deporting her would leave four U.S. her children without their mother’s care, or potentially force these citizens to leave the only home they have ever known for a country they’ve never even visited.

·         Maribel fled her home state in Mexico because of the extreme violence and terror inflicted by gangs and cartels. Her father was a victim of that violence less than two years ago. It is irresponsible to send her, and potentially her U.S. citizen children, into such harsh conditions.

·         For years under previous administrations, the U.S. government was not concerned about Maribel because she was an upstanding member of her community. Now, the current administration is using her, and others like her, to “make a point” that they are being tough on immigration. Taking immigrants without properly notifying their families and attorneys is unacceptable. The U.S. government should not be in the business of making people disappear, or harming families to push a political agenda.

·         As a lay leader in her parish, Maribel is an important part of her community. Last year, when Maribel was close to deportation, thousands of her supporters throughout Butler County and Cincinnati sent letters, pleading for her to stay. A woman like Maribel, tied to her community and working hard to support her family, is no threat to public safety and is not a flight risk.

If you are in or near Cincinnati, Ohio, please encourage people to participate in the “Mercy for Maribel” prayer service at 2 p.m. Sunday, April 9, to pray that she will not be deported, but be allowed to remain with her loving family in Hamilton.

Participants will gather at St. Joseph Church, 171 Washington Street, Hamilton, Ohio 45011, which is at the corner of Second and Washington Streets.  From there, they will pray the rosary in a procession from the church to the Butler County jail, about a 10-minute walk away.

Please follow our social media accounts on Facebook and Twitter (@cliniclegal) to stay up-to-date on Maribel’s case. We are also working to reopen her asylum case in the meantime.